Urša
Menart's fiction feature debut My Last Year as a Loser
premiered last year at the Slovenian Film Festival in Portorož to a
number of awards, including one for the best film. Later on it went
into the distribution followed by usually raving reviews of the
established film critics at home, focusing on its vibrancy regarding
the depicting of Slovenian youth struggling to make a decisive step
into the adulthood for a number of reasons that usually have nothing
to do with themselves individually or as a group. While Menart's film
undoubtedly has some strong points, as a whole it is also struggling
to break the patterns as it is the case with its protagonist.
We
meet Špela, played by Eva Jesenovec, also a debutante in a
feature format, in a good period of life that is about to end soon.
She lives with her computer programmer boyfriend in a rented
apartment and works two part-time jobs, as a swimming pool lifeguard
and at a reception desk of the museum. She has some high hopes for
the latter one, since she is an art historian and internships like
this usually progress into something more substantial. Her social
life, however, is not blossoming since two of her best friends went
abroad to chase their dreams.
The
things that follow could be described as a streak of bad luck. First,
her boyfriend goes to San Francisco to jump-start his career, leaving
Špela behind. Then the permanent job she considered to be a sure
thing slips out of her hands due to bureaucracy issues. Špela has to
move back to her parents, an unemployed father and over-worked
mother, and to sleep on the couch since her grandmother has moved
into her old room. Job prospects are slim: low-paid internships, some
volunteering, and she is not even eligible for student jobs, so she
has to go for scheme and "rent" someone's student status.
Meeting
her co-worker Suzi (Živa Selan, radiant and brilliant in a
role that usually plays out trashy) might prove to be her lucky break
because Suzi has the thing Špela lacks: the tough-as-nails attitude
that she will be fine no matter what. Špela quickly moves in with
her new friend and her misfit flatmates and for a while it seems she
"grows a pair". But is she really determined not to be a
loser any more? And, even if she is, will the world accept it?
Film-wise,
My Last Year as a Loser can be described as a Slovenian (or
Central-East-European) variation on mumblecore cinema in a more
modern way since it is not that dialogue-heavy and action-free.
Basically, it is a string of low-intensity events that actually feel
genuine for a post-student, but pre-work life of an individual on the
brink of 30's. So we have a bit of hanging around, a bit of partying
and some conversations that are not all that wise and unravelling as
they might seem to Špela and her friends, like the standard dilemma
"to leave or to stay and make your own environment better".
We also get a quirky and well-executed metaphor revolving around an
old bicycle that gets stolen. So, kudos to Menart for that.
The
writer-director documentary background also shows a bit, since Menart
has a talent to make the background of the film (the social landscape
of Slovenia and particularly Ljubljana, the gap between the
generations, the vignettes of student and post-student life) as
interesting, or even more interesting than the main plot. The
semi-autobiographical feeling can be read from a number of small
details and anecdotes she fills the film with, sometimes played for
whole-hearted laughs, sometimes landing not so well.
But
as a "hero's journey" type of film or a case study on how
good kids end up as "losers", as suggested in its very
strong title, Menart's film kinda drops the ball, since it is obvious
that it is not Špela's last year as a loser. Maybe it is intentional
irony from Menart's part, but there is no confirmation for that since
the writer-director is usually warm towards her protagonist, caring
and cheering for her most of the time. The key of the problem might
be even the heroine herself, since Špela seems more like a
collection of stereotypes about young hipster population than a real
person. I am not saying that that type of person does not exist,
because it certainly does, but questioning if that was Menart's
intention.
The
other problem is the structure, or the complete lack of it in a solid
form, so we get a number of sub-plots going nowhere and events
without consequences. Having that in mind, it is fair to be said that
My Last Year as a Loser is not tedious film, but it feels like
going in small circles, pretty much as its protagonist. Strong acting
by its young and vibrant cast (Timon Štrubej of Consequences fame
can also be seen in a small, but rewarding role) decent score and
appealing camerawork do the trick to a point, but not all the way. In
the end, My Last Year as a Loser is a decent (or even slightly
better than that) effort, but not exactly an admirable one.
No comments:
Post a Comment