previously published on Cineuropa
Will romance save us? Or is it dead, and are we living in a “post-romance world”? That is the question that young, up-and-coming Austrian filmmaker Isabella Brunäcker asks in her feature debut, Sugarland. Its world premiere has just taken place at the Diagonale, while its universal topic might make it a reasonably good fit for an international tour of small festivals.
Iga (Jana McKinnon, of The Trouble with Being Born fame) drives a car alone down the highways of Europe, taking the occasional break to smoke a cigarette at a petrol station. On one such occasion, Ethan (Bill Caple, glimpsed in The Buckingham Murders) asks her for a lighter, only to go even further and ask for a ride. Reluctant to have company in the car at first, Iga eventually offers to drive him to the next stop on the way.
They bond over the music they listen to and start opening up to each other: Iga admits that she is not dropping the car off for a friend, but driving all the way to Scotland to see her ex-boyfriend and bring him the stuff he left behind in Vienna after they broke up, while Ethan says he is coming back early from a party trip to Italy with his friends, subsequently admitting that he is trying to find himself and attempting to make some money in order to go back to studies that he abandoned earlier.
The “next stop” keeps getting postponed. It seems that there is some chemistry between them, but no one has enough determination to take one final step. Or is it all just the random stuff people tell each other to kill time while travelling together? Anyhow, a turn of events just before they board a ferry to cross the English Channel will expose the truth about them, their vulnerabilities and their position in life.
Brunäcker fights an uphill battle initially, given that the whole first half of the film is virtually devoid of a plot and serves only as exposition for the third-act developments. Sure, the filmmaker has to start slowly, but the whole setup where we have two ordinary people in an ordinary and very static situation proves to be a huge obstacle, if not a burden. There are films that subvert viewers’ expectations, but Sugarland is not Richard Linklater’s Before Sunrise, even though Brunäcker tries to channel that kind of energy, and the two leads draw inspiration from Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy, too. However, the setting of a city to walk and talk in proves to be far more interesting than one of motorways and motels. Once the plot kicks in, though, Sugarland becomes a way smoother watch that eloquently checks the boxes of contemporary young people’s anxieties.
The filmmaker eventually answers the questions from the first paragraph – not directly, but with a hint that has been with us right from the start. Sugarland was filmed on 16 mm stock by cinematographer Matthias Helldoppler, which seems quite romantic in today’s digital age. More than this, it creates a sense of natural warmth, even if the weather is misty, the landscapes are grey and mundane, and the characters try to keep each other at a safe distance in order to prevent themselves from falling in love and getting heartbroken too quickly. The romance of film tape might not be able to save the world, but it could just save cinema and a movie like Sugarland.